The Labor of the Five-Inch Stage
The blue light of the screen at 5:44 AM is a harsh judge, highlighting the micro-lines around my eyes that no amount of moisturizing can fully erase before the first meeting of the day. My thumb is currently cramping because I am on the 24th attempt to capture a ‘natural’ yawn. You know the one-the kind of yawn that suggests I have just woken up in a state of effortless grace, my hair perfectly tousled in a way that says ‘I don’t care,’ even though I spent at least 14 minutes carefully arranging the strands to look like they haven’t been touched. This is the ritual. This is the labor of the modern creator. We are all currently engaged in the most exhaustive, high-stakes theatrical production in human history, and the stage is a five-inch vertical rectangle. We call it authenticity, but if we were being honest, we would call it architectural sincerity. It is a structure built to look like a garden, but every weed is placed there by design.
The Incoherent Grunt and the Edited Failure
I tried to respond, a series of 114 guttural grunts that were meant to be a nuanced take on the commodification of the soul. He nodded as if I’d just delivered a TED Talk.
– The Dentist’s Chair
I realized the absurdity of this recently while sitting in a dentist’s chair, my mouth propped open by 4 different plastic implements. My dentist, a man who seems to take a perverse pleasure in asking complex philosophical questions while his patients are physically incapable of speech, asked me what I thought about the ‘state of the internet.’ That interaction was, perhaps, the only authentic thing that happened to me all week-a messy, incoherent failure of communication. But I couldn’t post that. Or rather, I could, but only if I framed it with the right lighting, a self-deprecating caption, and a 44-percent increase in my usual level of curated vulnerability.
This brings me to the core frustration: the demand for realness is actually a demand for a very specific, polished brand of reliability. Audiences don’t actually want to see your 4:04 AM panic attack unless it’s followed by a 14-step guide on how you ‘overcame’ it with a specific green juice. They don’t want the raw, bleeding edge of a human life; they want a narrative arc. They want the ‘hero’s journey’ in 64 seconds or less. We have turned our personalities into products, and in doing so, we have entered a state of profound alienation where we are both the worker and the commodity being sold.